Pull the prop. then mark the hub and the prop with a bit of paint or a magic marker. put the prop on and run it until you feel the slipping. pull the prop again and check the marks to see if they are still lined up. if not take it to a prop shop and get the hub replaced. Cheaper than a new prop.
This works and it is easy to do.
But also take the advice of the other idea about the prop sucking air.
This happens sometimes if the outboard is mounted too high on the transom.
Mine sucks a l;ittle and cavitates if I horse it too tight into a turn.
I decided to try a 4 blade SS prop this year to reduce or eliminate this effect.
But I would also like to comment on a 16 year old 2-stroke selling for $2K....
Sounds a little bit high.
But if the hours are low and it can be proven.....
Good luck.