My opinion if you cast I'd steer clear of line counters. I'm a die hard muskie fisherman from iceout to iceup. I'm hard on my gear between rough conditions and big fish. I cast, troll, and fish suckers in the fall. In the beginning (7 years ago) I needed a reel that did it all. I was cheep and bought a couple round baitcasters with clickers (about $100 a piece). They didn't last 2 years! I am NOT brand married and now own several different brand reels for different applications. If you are looking for the best do it all reel, I own 2 Abu nacl reels just for that reason. One thing I'd recommend, do NOT get anything with less than a 20# drag weight!! That lesson has cost me many fish! Shoot me a pm with your number and I'd be happy to let you try mine out.