Trophy? I agree it is in the eye of the beholder. I believe that if it leaves a lasting memory, then it is a trophy. Still remember a 15 - 16 inch yellow bass below Monroe Reservoir that I lost. Doesn't sound like much to most but the memory of that fish still lingers.Not to start a "war" but a couple of fish in those pics look like redears but do not have the classic red spot on ear flap. I realize that they will cross with bluegills (right?), do you call it an 'ear or a 'gill?
I don't see any redear in any of those pics. They are bluegill (some are faded from being in the cooler or livewell before pics) or pumpkinseeds in these pics. The seeds will have red on the ear. Sometimes it is bright red and other times faded or barely visible. Redear also don't have the colors throughout the sides like a seed does.