The add for Crowduck should read: Crowduck, Great fishing for all the wrong reasons!
I went into Crowduck with my dad and brother last summer (day trip arranged through the lodge). They came and picked us up from the boat launch on Big Whiteshell, ferried us across the Lake and drove us by truck to Crowduck Lake Lodge. They had the boat running when we got there. Gave us a map, and a few basic instructions and off we went.
The Lake is beautiful, clear water and crisp Canadian Shield. I was very impressed. The fishing was simply amazing in terms of numbers caught, definitely up there in my Top 10 for most fish caught in a day. Although we sort of lost count, we estimated our catch at 150 walleye and 2 pike between the three of us. Once we found the fish, the action was fast and furious.
Despite what seems like a flawless trip, I was left with a bad taste. The fish of Crowduck Lake are definetly not healthy. All of the fish we caught were between 19-23", but weighed more of what 15-17" walleye should weigh. 75% of the fish had really large heads, and very small bodies. The other thing we noticed after heading up to Crowduck Falls (wich happened to be littered with dead walleye carcasses), were that the walleye would hit our lures in less than 5 feet of water with the motor running! It appears these fish are starving.
I understand the history behind Crowduck, and realize that Conservation is using it as a test lake for the catch and release policy following intensive stocking efforts. Just be aware that as a result of this policy, the walleye do look sickly. A novice fisherman might not notice, but the experienced walleye fisherman definitely would. For me personally, I would not go back unless something changes.
According to lodge operator (Bill Kalinsky), our experience was the normal and not an exception (although the other day trip group that went in with us only caught 11 fish!). If you want to go to catch a load of walleye, go to Crowduck by all means. But don't expect to catch any big fish (there don't seem to be many anymore), and be aware that the fish are unhealthy.
Sorry for the rant, but I just didn't like what I saw.
Ashnohgrimbatul
perch pounder
Jr. Member
Posts: 24
Re: opening day hotspot
« Reply #19 on: Today at 03:29:35pm » Reply with quote
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I have heard the same thing too about the skinny walleyes . I fell that they (government) should allow anglers to take a few for shore lunch . This would not even make a dent in the population if 3 people can catch 150 walleyes on an average day.
Report to moderator Logged
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
here fishy , fishy , fishy.......
Ashnohgrimbatul
Jr. Member
Posts: 21
Re: opening day hotspot
« Reply #20 on: Today at 03:50:01pm » Reply with quote Modify Remove
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Yeah it makes you wonder....in a way I commend the government for sticking with there original intent to have a great Catch and Release walleye fishery but at the same time, I don't think starving the population is the way to maintain such a great fishery.
Report to moderator Logged
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Early to bed, early to rise,
fish like hell, and make up lies.
big walleye
Jr. Member
Posts: 43
Re: opening day hotspot
« Reply #21 on: Today at 07:36:40pm » Reply with quote
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
To many walleyes in crowduck. This use to be such a trophy lake. I respect what the government has done but now it is time to change policy. Let the anglers keep some. These fish should not die of starvation. I hate to say this but a few years ago Lake of the Prairies had walleye that looked very similiar. The heavy netting which I do not approve of may of infact helped the fishery in a sense. the walleye I caught last. year were nice and fat. Crowduck may benefit with controlled netting for one year. I really hate saying that but what else can you do.
Report to moderator Logged
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Who cares if the bite is on. You could be at work!!!
Nightcrawler
Jr. Member
Posts: 15
Re: opening day hotspot
« Reply #22 on: Today at 07:40:56pm » Reply with quote
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I've had the exact same experience. By the way there's lots of big smallie's in there as well! But the walleye competition is out of control on "the lake of two birds", last time I was in there was 4 summers ago, and when we ran out of crawlers we used fat elastic bands and there was no difference. I also haven't heard of too many trophy's coming out of there as of late. Every year the rumor comes out that angler's will be allowed to keep a couple of fish for shorelunch, yet it never happens. But I always thought that the lodge owner(s) had something to do with the fact that all fish had to be released. Surely they would get to have some input wouldn't they? They would know better than anyone in regards to average sizes and trophy's caught year to year as they are the only outfitter on the lake. Any thoughts? Is this a new post perhaps?
Report to moderator Logged
Ashnohgrimbatul
Jr. Member
Posts: 21
Re: opening day hotspot
« Reply #23 on: Today at 09:39:06pm » Reply with quote Modify Remove
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The sick thing is that i'm sure the lodge owner gets tons of business still...alot based on people who used to come when the fish were healthier, and also alot from novice fisherman. In terms of a fish stock that is easily catchable, nothing is better than starving fish. It wouldn't suprise me at all that he would want the lake to remain Catch and Release.
