From what I understand, musky fishing is actually very good at night. Fishing for pike at night is almost impossible, because a pike's eye lacks the ability to see well in dark water. However, muskies have a more advanced eye structure, so they feed 'round the clock. Muskies bite especiallly well after dark on lakes where there is a lot of day time boat traffic. A few weeks ago, I was fishing for bass at night. I was throwing a 5 inch black and silver Zara Spook. I have an LED headlight, which allows me to watch my lure all the way in. I began walking the dog and I see this bulge start to form behind the lure. WAM!!! This tiger musky slams that spook. I set the hook and for about 10 seconds, he was hooked good. Then it made a run and snapped my 12 lb. Trilene like nothing. So that was my experience with nighttime muskies. I'll be back to that rockpile...but I'll be using a wire leader next time!
-Zach