MyFishFinder Forum
My Fish Finder Main => General Fishing Discussion => Topic started by: fishmaster13184 on Mar 26, 2008, 09:57 AM
-
i thought brown but someone told me it was a salmon i caught it steel head fishing in a tributary of lake ontario
(https://www.myfishfinder.com/fishing_forum/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fi259.photobucket.com%2Falbums%2Fhh314%2Fbigal13184%2F0325081440a.jpg&hash=53ac76823810eb37540c7cd2a958f984)
(https://www.myfishfinder.com/fishing_forum/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fi259.photobucket.com%2Falbums%2Fhh314%2Fbigal13184%2F0325081440.jpg&hash=8bb3eb7a1548a7d11896499b437fd9bb)
-
Pictures are really fuzzy, hard to tell.
-
Looks like a salmon to me , not enough spots for a brown
-
well that has me really confused because i caught over 20 browns that day and they all looked the same, i also got a about 10 steelies that all looked the same then i got this one that looked like a mix of a bow and a brown, dont know if that is possible or what but that was the only one i have ever seen look like that and i have cought tons of fish fishing up there
-
It's a brown.
-
if the head or tail or both had been clear in the pictures, it would have been easy.
-
i agree the best way to tell is in the tooth pattern in on the tongue
-
Did you Tail it ? It's kinda hard to tell but if it was as you described " bow and brown like " I'd lean toward it being an Atlantic. It does look to me like it has a bit of a butter belly going which says brown to me.
-
Although the spots look more like Atlantic than not- the coloring of the belly & fin definately look more Brown. Did it fight much different?
-
fuzzy pictures but I would say brown as they can get really lite but I could very well be wrong as the pics are pretty fuzzy
-
That shure looks like an Atlantic Salmon to me, Did the bottom jaw have upward curve? 30 years of trib fishing during spring and fall never seen a spring brown with coloring like that
-
s
i thought brown but someone told me it was a salmon i caught it steel head fishing in a tributary of lake ontario
(https://www.myfishfinder.com/fishing_forum/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fi259.photobucket.com%2Falbums%2Fhh314%2Fbigal13184%2F0325081440a.jpg&hash=53ac76823810eb37540c7cd2a958f984)
(https://www.myfishfinder.com/fishing_forum/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fi259.photobucket.com%2Falbums%2Fhh314%2Fbigal13184%2F0325081440.jpg&hash=8bb3eb7a1548a7d11896499b437fd9bb)
so did you find out what is was ????????????????????????
-
no idea what it was some say salmon some say brown? i usually only practice cpr( except for a couple steelies for eggs) so this fish is probably back in the lake by now for someone else to catch
-
That shure looks like an Atlantic Salmon to me, Did the bottom jaw have upward curve? 30 years of trib fishing during spring and fall never seen a spring brown with coloring like that
I'm with this guy....atlantic salmon for sure...
-
Looks like a Lake Ontario brown that just came in the trib. The yellow belly and the shape of the spots look more like a brown to me... better pixs would make easier to tell..... Most of the guys I know that egg fish would rather have brown eggs......Please let the steelies go.... their numbers are dwindling
-
Pics a little fuzzy but I would say brown ;)
Ral
-
In the DITCH your standing near ::) ::) ::) I'd say brown ::) Poor pics make it impossible to ID . NY stocks two different strains of brown trout I think one is the german brown and the other is a seaforellen ( sp ?? ) which has very sparse spotting and grown somewhat larger but I could be wrong.
HMMM going to have to dig a little and get some research done.
-
That is a brown trout without a doubt
-
in all my experiences, i will have to say brown for sure and a pretty nice one to! good job.
-
That's a brown for sure. ::)
-
its a brown trout for sure nice job. what trib were you fishing? if i might ask!
-
If you look at the fin on the belly of the first pic you can see that there is a white stripe on the edge of it. I think this is only comon in trout. I would guess that its a brown trout of some strain.
-
i'll vote for not enough spots for a brown.......atlantic
-
i'll vote for not enough spots for a brown.......atlantic
an atlantic has x's for [spots]
-
an atlantic has x's for [spots]
Exactly
-
I'm betting it's a Rome Strain brown trout. I'm going by the white edged fin, never seen an Atlantic/LL with white edged fins.
-
ide bet the farm its a brown..... :tipup:
-
Brownie, no doubt...
The first few Browns that I caught from the Rondout Reservoir in the Catskills looked just like it... They are the "Seeforellen" trout that are mentioned above by Dull Hooks.
They grow rediculously big (20lb Browns are not unusual in the NYC Water Supplies- but some 15lb fish are only 25" long! Fatties!
I thought they were 'escapee' Landlockers from the Neversink Reservoir... But after awhile I realized that they were just fat Browns without so much coloring as normal.
No doubt that yours is the same. Good looking fish- but it's hard to beat the beauty of the butter-colored bad boys when they are all bright and yellowish...
-
(https://www.myfishfinder.com/fishing_forum/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fi104.photobucket.com%2Falbums%2Fm170%2Fbobbydaddy8%2Ftn.jpg&hash=7099d535915e06cbd0a5539443d32757)
20" 5lbs, local river, on a night crawler.
-
this topic is getting warn a little thin on here and the shanty
-
BROWNIE= NICE ONE 2