I have been fishing from Deer Horn Lodge since 1981. Try to go up every year. Walleye fishing is getting alot better these days while the trophy pike are much harder to catch. On average we have been catching 8 to 10 lb pike and 3 to 5 lb walleye.
The nice thing about Deer Horn is that its pretty secluded and there is no trouble from the local Indians as I heard about at the other places (Pavilion Cabonga/Bark Lake Lodge).
The only drawback is there is an 18 mile drive on a rock road which, if you are pulling a boat, the fastest you can go is about 20 mph.
The beauty of the Cabonga is the variety of the lake. I read there is something like 2000 miles of shore line. There are inlets and bays that you can fish and fish and fish. That is one of the reasons we keep going back every year is due to the variety that the Cabonga has to offer and peacefulness that Deer Horn Offers.
The first year there (1981) I did catch a 44 inch 38 lb northern. And don't get me wrong, big ones are still caught but it seems mostly by trolling deep holes with plugs.
Let me know if you want any more information.