There was a large re-distribution of fish during the flooding last year. If the rivers waters met the lake it's very possible.
That is what I am being told. The bait fish and trout are beaching themselves to escape the ravaging attacks! I'm heading there after work today, or tomorrow to check it out.
I've still never hooked 1 on the fly (can't really say I've ever tried though either), but they are fun on the centerpin in the trout streams I fish for em in over the summer every one I saw roll was up against the bank on the RT11 side of the lake and theres almost no room to swing flies because of the brush. From the other side of the lake you should be able to get a clear cast across from the "piers" they have that extend out half way into the lake
THE RIVER OVERFLOWED IN COXTON IN 06 AND 11where i rabbit hunt is now small lakes or ponds.these water areas now hold bass eyes pike carp muskies and huge catfish.i dont know what they eat or how they survive.i do know that my rabbit hotspot is now a fishing hotspot somedays.this is what i would guess happened at this lake..
if you are talking about the place im thinking of,where the lackawanna flows into the susky in that area those ponds were actually built there by the landfill thats in taylor,the state made them replace wetlands that they destroyed when they built the landfill,there conected to the susky and thats how they get filled up,its not the same down there sence the flood last year but they do hold some decent fish